MENU
Antique sterling silver can range from a modest heirloom to a high-ticket collectible. But how do you know what it’s truly worth? The answer isn’t always obvious at first glance, and determining value involves more than checking for a hallmark or polish.
Collectors, appraisers, and even casual sellers must evaluate a mix of factors—age, condition, craftsmanship, rarity, and silver content all play a role. Here’s how to take a smart, thorough approach to valuing antique sterling silver.
Before anything else, it’s important to define what counts as sterling silver. In most countries, sterling refers to a silver alloy that is 92.5% pure silver, with the remaining 7.5% typically made up of copper. This ratio has been standard for centuries and offers both durability and luster.
You’ll often see this noted with a “.925” stamp or the word “Sterling” engraved on the item. However, some antique pieces may use older symbols or national hallmarks that don’t say “sterling” outright. In these cases, identifying the origin and confirming purity through a silver test may be necessary.
Hallmarks are small stamped symbols or letters found on sterling silver pieces—often located in inconspicuous spots like the underside of a tray or the base of a candlestick. These marks can reveal:
Older British pieces may include a lion passant, indicating sterling quality, while French silver uses the Minerva head. American manufacturers usually use the word “Sterling” or “.925.” Learning to read and interpret hallmarks can be a fast-track way to understanding a piece’s history and value.
While silver content sets a baseline for intrinsic value, the condition and craftsmanship can push a piece well above melt weight.
Does the item have dents, heavy tarnish, or signs of repair? Has the original detailing worn down from over-polishing? These imperfections can negatively impact value. On the other hand, ornate chasing, hand engraving, repoussé work, or signatures from notable silversmiths can significantly raise a piece’s desirability.
Unusual or artistic forms—like figural pieces, novelty designs, or limited editions—often fetch more on the market due to their aesthetic and collectible appeal.
Many assume older equals more valuable, but that’s not always the case. A mass-produced sterling tray from 1850 might be worth less than a well-crafted midcentury piece from a respected studio.
Still, age does play a part, especially if the item was made during a notable artistic or historical period. Victorian, Art Nouveau, and Arts and Crafts-era silver can be especially sought after, depending on the style and maker.
Because silver has a consistent market price, weight provides a useful starting point for value—even if it’s not the whole picture.
A large sterling punch bowl, for instance, may have a substantial melt value due to the sheer amount of silver used. However, if it's by a well-known maker or has intricate handwork, its worth can far exceed the weight-based estimate.
Remember, plated silver does not carry intrinsic silver value. Be cautious of the difference—especially with pieces marked EPNS (Electro Plated Nickel Silver) or “silver on copper.”
Some names in the world of antique silver carry extra weight. Pieces from Tiffany & Co., Gorham, Jensen, or Fabergé, for example, often bring premium prices—especially if rare, limited, or part of a complete set.
Maker’s marks are often found near the hallmark and can help link an item to a specific workshop or designer. Rarity also plays a role. If few examples of a particular piece exist, it’s more likely to command attention and a higher valuation.
Value is ultimately what someone is willing to pay. That means demand can shift depending on trends, collector interest, and even decor styles.
While traditional silver tea sets have seen fluctuating interest in recent years, smaller decorative objects, barware, and unique conversation pieces have held stronger appeal with modern buyers.
Checking current auction results, online sales, and antique dealer pricing can help give a sense of what similar items are selling for—not just what they’re listed at.
Antique sterling silver carries a mix of history, artistry, and material value. Learning how to evaluate all these aspects—from hallmarks and condition to rarity and market trends—can help you better understand what your piece is truly worth. Whether you’re holding a family heirloom or a flea market find, the key is in the details.
