MENU
Selling silver isn’t always as simple as checking the current spot price and heading to the nearest refinery. Depending on the type of silver you have, you might be leaving money on the table—or sitting on something more valuable than you realize.
The decision to sell silver as scrap or through auction or resale channels depends on a few key variables: form, maker, condition, and market demand. This guide breaks down how to evaluate your options and choose the most profitable (and sensible) path.
The term "scrap silver" generally refers to any silver item being sold solely for its metal content. This includes:
The value in these cases comes down to purity and weight. Most commonly, sterling silver (marked “925”) will sell for a percentage of the current silver spot price. Items marked “800” or “coin silver” trade lower due to reduced purity. Electroplated pieces (often marked “EPNS” or “silverplate”) contain no appreciable silver and typically have no melt value.
In other words, if your item is not collectible, isn’t made by a known maker, or is too damaged to restore, scrap pricing is likely the best-case scenario.
Not all silver is created equal. Some pieces, while technically made of the same metal, carry far more value due to their history, craftsmanship, or design. These are the pieces that belong in auctions or curated resale environments.
Consider auction if your silver falls into one or more of the following categories:
In these cases, the market value of the item can exceed its melt value many times over. Selling such a piece as scrap would not only be unwise—it would be a loss.
A common gray area comes up with incomplete sets or odd serving pieces. A lone sterling ladle or orphaned teaspoon might not seem valuable at first glance—but certain patterns or makers can still generate interest from collectors or people looking to complete their own sets.
Before melting down anything, it’s worth checking whether the piece fits into a known pattern or service line. You may be surprised at what sells—especially if the pattern is discontinued or difficult to find.
That said, damaged or overly worn pieces, even if antique, may not warrant the attention of collectors. At some point, condition and practicality overtake history in determining value.
There are times when even “interesting” silver is better off being sold as scrap. For instance:
Market timing also plays a role. During silver price surges, it may make more sense to scrap less desirable pieces quickly and lock in a high return. Conversely, during quieter periods, collectible silver may outperform its melt value due to sustained collector demand.
If you're unsure whether your silver should be scrapped or sold for its collectible value, a visual inspection can help—but only to a point. Hallmarks, monograms, pattern names, and construction details can all offer clues, but interpretation requires experience.
When in doubt, it’s worth seeking an appraisal or at least comparing similar items across secondary marketplaces (SebastianCharles Auctions can help with this!). Too many people melt down pieces assuming they’re worthless, only to find out later they gave away something far more valuable than the metal it contained.
Scrapping silver makes sense when you're dealing with common, damaged, or non-collectible items. But once age, maker, rarity, or design come into play, it may be worth exploring the resale or auction route.
In many cases, the choice between scrap and auction is less about silver content—and more about context. Understanding that difference can mean the margin between a modest payout and a meaningful one.
